Skip to main content
Pecan Pie, front of the package

A Southern classic, made the way we think it should be.

Rich and full, this pecan pie is made with cane syrup, sugar, and honey—never corn syrup.

It's sweet, but balanced, letting the pecans carry the flavor.

It's the kind of pie that finds its way to the center of the table—and stays there.

Details:

  • Baked in our farm bakery with pecans grown here at Koinonia Farm
  • Made without corn syrup— sweetened with cane syrup, organic sugar, and honey
  • Full-size pie
  • Perfect for holidays, gatherings, or sharing

Ingredients: Filling: Eggs, organic cane syrup, organic sugar (organic evaporated cane juice and molasses), raw honey, organic pecans, butter (pasteurized cream, salt), vanilla (vanilla extract, alcohol), organic flour (organic wheat flour, niacin, iron, thiamin mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid)
Shell: Enriched wheat flour (wheat flour, niacin, organic wheat flour, reduced iron, thiamin mononitrate, riboflavin, folic acid), soybean oil, water, hydrogenated soybean oil, dextrose, salt, dough conditioner (sodium metabisulfite)

CONTAINS: Eggs, dairy, wheat, tree nuts (Pecans)

All Koinonia products may contain traces of peanuts, tree nuts, dairy, or wheat.

Pecan Pie

Vendor: Koinonia Farm
Regular price $26.25

Pre-order now for End of October Shipping!

Learn more about shipping and weather

  • 5 stars: 38 (97%)
  • 4 stars: 1 (3%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
L
Lenny Jordan
Best Pecan Pie

Who would have thought a pecan pie that was shipped could be better than the homemade pies I have made at home for years!! I loved that it was more healthy and tasted better than my own.
Everyone loved it.

M
Mark
Pecan Pie

I loved this pie

B
Betty Hanson
Special gift

receiver reported it was delicious and arrived intact undamaged.

G
Gail Mot
Pecan pie

It was the unanimous opinion of my family of pecan pie lovers that your pecan pie was the best by far of anything they had ever tasted! Next time I'll buy two!

F
Frances Smith
Pecan Pie

This was a real hit at our family Thanksgiving. Just right!

L
Linda
Just the right sweetness!

Tasting this pie is a revelation of how pecan pie can be! Some pecan pies are "deadly" sweet but not this one. The texture is substantial but not "jelly-like". It is quite rich enough but not cloying. It is a pie I'm proud to serve to guests and never worry that they only want a "sliver"! I hope you never change the recipe!

G
Gary Williams
Pecan Pie

I always look forward to having Koinonia's Pecan Pie for the holidays. It is scrumptious. The pecans are fresh and the pie has just the right amount of sweetness. A real treat.

J
John Omerod
PECAN PIE

Best I've ever had! Lots of nuts!

J
Jon Shafer
Pecan pie

Nuts all the way through, not just on top! And not too sweet like many other versions.

P
Paul Anderson
Temptingly delicious!

Lots of pecans, just right balance of sweet and savory. Delicious to the point of temptation to over-eat!

T
Ted Bloch
Pecan Pie

I bought this as a gift for a neighbor. She said it was "ridiculously delicious!"

J
Judy May
Pecan Pie

I order it each year when I visit my brother and we have early Thanksgiving dinner. It is SOOO good--a much appreciated gift and I get to eat some too!

J
Jill
Pecan pie

Never ordered this from you before. WOW -very sweet, but delicious. My husband's favorite. Delivery was very fast. Thank you.

P
Pam Marshall
Best ever pecan pie

I have ordered pecan pies from Koinonia over the last 6 years as gifts and family dinners both. Everyone loves them!! The flavor is outstanding and pecans are the true star. You can always count on the consistent quality and prompt delivery.

D
David Shelton
Pecan Pie

YUM!!! We ordered a pie for our family for Christmas. It was a big hit! Thank you Koinonia Farm!

L
Lisa
Mom loves the pie!!!

My 87 year old mother ate almost the whole pie before Thanksgiving. Her caregiver kept hiding it from her and she kept finding it! There wasn't much left for Thanksgiving... So, that sums up the popularity of this pie in our family!

T
Ted
Pecan Pie

Delicious. Text is wonderful. Not to sweet -- not too much corny syrup. Really perfection!!

M
Monica
The best!

I bought 2 pecan pies for Thanksgiving: one for a friend and one for my guests. Both were gone in a flash and thoroughly enjoyed. Such a delicious way to enjoy Koinonia's wonderful pecans. I may have to order another one...........

j
jane
Delicious pecan pie!

As a Georgian, I know pecans and I know about Koinonia. I was delighted to order a pecan pie for the family Thanksgiving feast. It was delicious and gratifying to know that a part was helping the mission of Koinonia!

Y
Young Rhie
PEACAN PIE

It was an unusual and unique pie. I shared it with my friends and they did like and enjoy it very much.

J
Judy May
Pecan Pie

The pie tastes wonderful and packaged well so it arrives quickly and in good condition. I've ordered twice for early Thanksgiving dinner when I visit my brother, who loves it too. At the dinner with friends, it's a chance to tell about the history and present of your good works. Other guests wanted to know how to order from you.

K
Karen Harrison
Pecan pie

Scrumptious and full of love!! I love this pie so much that I bought them, big and small, for all my local friends and also had them sent to Georgia and Louisiana to new friends I met while on the road. They arrived in great shape and everybody loved them! They are a wonderful gift any time of year. It warms my heart and fills my soul to have found something so good in a place with a history of standing up for what's right and serving folks who need help. If you love pecan pie, I encourage you to buy them here. You will enjoy the pie and enjoy the kudos you get for giving them to your friends while also helping those who are in despair. And you help this amazing historical farm keep doing what it's doing, spreading the love around! Everyone wins! Thank you, Koinonia!

K
Karen Ivy
Pecan Mini pies

These little pies are delicious and make a wonderful one person dessert! They are full of pecan flavor.

D
Daria Savickas
Pecan pie

The peacan pie was so delicious! We enjoyed it so much that it was gone in no time !

R
Rev. Rich Peacock
Pecan Pie

It was full with an abundance of pecans and super delicious!

C
Chapman R D
Pecan Pie

We decided to send a pecan pie to our mother for part of her Mother's Day package. She is a great baker and always making special treats for the family. We were very pleased that she absolutely loved the pie!!

L
Lisa
Mini Pecan Pies

We forgot to buy the ingredients to make a pecan pie for our Covid Thanksgiving and so we ordered two mini pies to have at another special time. We ate them last night and it was worth the wait!! They were delicious and perfectly sized for those wanting a little comfort food, but not wanting to over indulge. And, best of all, they were delicious and not overly sweet, like most pecan pies I've had. Thank you again, Koinonia!

L
Lee
Pecan Pie - 5 stars for the pie. Only 3 stars for the Post Office

My pie arrived two days later than it was supposed to, which was not Koinonia's fault. I had ordered one full-sized pie and one small pie as a gift. The post office kept sending me updates that were pretty much meaningless. To my relief, the pies were intact when they arrived and I froze them immediately. I was a bit frustrated that I couldn't get a response from a human at the K. Farm or at the post office. I wanted to know if it was safe to eat, but I froze both pies and hoped that would take care of anything. I gave the tiny pie to a friend who loves pie but is diabetic. It was smaller than it seemed to look online. It is a TINY pie but my friend got a kick out of it and it was really all that a diabetic person should have. A sugar-free version of the pie would be great for Koinonia to have. The pie is delicious. The pecans are the best.

K
Kate Killebrew
Pecan Pie

Absolutely wonderful pie and so fresh!

L
L P Chiles
YUM!

The reason I tried this pie was that it had no corn syrup in it. I have a corn allergy. Having not ordered a fresh pie online, I wasn't sure if it would arrive in crumbles.
This pie (2lb) was in perfect gorgeous condition! And the packing is made from spun sugar!? A science class for my grandchildren in recycling.
The pecans were so fresh and unprocessed and the entire pie was just delicious. It was just my daughter and myself, so I ended up freezing half of it. When we got it out, the taste was just as fresh. Really a great pie experience!

M
Melanie N.
Pecan Pie

This is first time we ordered the pecan pie, and we were not disappointed. No exaggeration - it is the best and freshest pecan pie we have had in recent memory. Thank you!

D
Dr. Jonathan Goodson
Pecan Pie

I love pecan pie, and this is absolutely the BEST I have ever tried!!

H
Helen Carlock
Pecan Pie

This pie is always a hit. I ordered one for family as a Christmas gift and just got the thank you note: "Thank you so much for the most delicious pecan pie. It was the best I had ever tasted and was enjoyed by the family."